My MIL Stole Eggs from My Fridge

Eggs have become a luxury these days, especially with kids in the house.

We barely eat them ourselves — they’re mostly for the kids. But every time

my mother-in-law, Andrea, came over, more eggs would mysteriously vanish.

Suspicious, I set up a hidden camera. And what did I catch? Andrea stuffing

eggs into her bag and walking straight to my neighbor, Mrs. Davis — and

selling them. For cash. Later, I casually asked Mrs. Davis where she got her eggs.

“Oh, your sweet MIL! She has backyard chickens and sells me eggs for just

$4 a dozen!” FOUR dollars. Andrea was stealing our eggs and running a side

hustle right next door. I was furious — but instead of yelling, I decided

to teach her a lesson. I spent over an hour hollowing out a whole carton of

eggs, draining them completely. Then I carefully refilled each one with a

mixture of mustard and hot sauce. As I worked late into the night, my husband

James walked in. “Is that… mustard?” he asked. “No,” I said. “It’s justice.

Sweet, yellow justice.” That weekend, Andrea showed up as usual. After greeting

the kids, she headed into the kitchen, “just for a glass of water.” I pretended

to be busy helping our son with homework, but I had my phone open, watching the

live camera feed. She took the eggs. Moments later, she handed them off to Mrs.

Davis and returned like nothing happened. That evening, I invited Andrea to have

tea with me on the porch — with a perfect view of Mrs. Davis’s kitchen window.

We watched as Mrs. Davis started baking. Then — a scream. She’d cracked one of

the eggs, and the mustard-hot sauce mix had exploded everywhere. Andrea jumped.

“What was that?” she asked. Just then — a loud knock on our door. Mrs. Davis

stormed in, furious, hands covered in mustard. “Those eggs!” she yelled. “They

were filled with… with…” “Eggs?” I asked innocently. “Oh, you mean the ones

Andrea sold you?” Mrs. Davis turned to Andrea in disbelief. “You stole these

from Rebecca?” Andrea’s face turned bright red. “What did you do?” she hissed at me.

“I think the real question is — what were you doing stealing and selling my groceries?”

I replied. Mrs. Davis was shocked. “I told everyone at bridge club about your eggs!”

she snapped at Andrea before storming out. Andrea didn’t stay much longer.

She grabbed her purse and left in a hurry. When James came home and I told

him everything, he couldn’t stop laughing. “That’s what you were doing with

the mustard? That’s evil genius level,” he said. “Note to self: never mess

with your groceries.” Andrea never brought it up again. Mrs. Davis found a

new egg supplier. And our eggs? They finally stayed where they belonged

— in our fridge. And every time I open the fridge, I smile.

Because few things taste as sweet as catching a thief — with mustard

Related Posts

The Hidden Problem Behind an Everyday Wall

A small dirt trail on a wall may look harmless, but it can be an early warning sign of termites. These trails often develop into mud tubes—narrow…

What Diane Keaton Shared About Her Health and Life Over the Years

Diane Keaton, the Oscar-winning star of Annie Hall and one of Hollywood’s most beloved originals, passed away in California on October 11, 2025, at age 79. Her…

The Hidden Traits of Green Eyes

Green eyes, found in only about 2% of the world’s population, have long symbolized mystery and allure. Their rarity makes them one of the most captivating eye…

What Happens When You Eat Expired Cans

Many people toss canned foods once the date has passed, but most of those labels—like “Best By” or “Best Before”—indicate quality, not safety. In fact, properly stored…

He Mocked Me While I Juggled 3 Kids — But I Had the Last Word

I never expected one text to change everything. Standing in the grocery store, juggling three kids and exhaustion, my phone buzzed. It was my husband, Dorian—criticizing how…

Diane Keaton’s Sudden Health Emergency in Los Angeles – What We Know So Far

Oscar-winning actress and Hollywood legend Diane Keaton was rushed from her Los Angeles home to a nearby hospital after a sudden medical emergency, prompting an outpouring of…